r SYZ n Fann Wong National Treasure?
-
范文芳ã€�å™ç‡•å§¿ 是ä¸�是国å®�?
范文芳ã€�å™ç‡•å§¿æ˜¯“国å®�”ï¼Ÿç½‘æ°‘ç½‘ä¸Šè´¨ç–‘ï¼šä¸¤äººæ²¡èµ„æ ¼ï¼�　
两人被ä¸å›½åª’体å°�ä¸ºæ–°åŠ å�¡çš„“国å®�级阿å§�”，而本地媒体也称她们为“国产å®�è´�”，有网民å�´è®¤ä¸ºè¿™ä¸ªå¸½å�扣得太大，两人ä¸�å¤Ÿèµ„æ ¼ã€‚
部长ã€�议员和文化音ä¹�界人士å�—访，谈谈他们的看法，说说他们对“国å®�”的定义。
有网民这两天在本地一娱ä¹�论å�›å¼€è…”质疑：范文芳ã€�å™ç‡•å§¿è¢«å½“国å®�，定义何在？该å��网å�‹æ˜¯æœ‰æ„ŸäºŽèŒƒæ–‡èŠ³ä¸Žå™ç‡•å§¿ï¼Œæœ€è¿‘频频被ä¸å›½åª’ä½“å† ä¸Š“国å®�级阿å§�”的称å�·ï¼Œè§‰å¾—ä¸�太æ�°å½“ï¼Œå› æ¤ä¸Šç½‘æ��问，应如何为“国å®�”å�šå®šä¹‰ï¼Ÿ
æ¤è´´ä¸€å‡ºï¼Œå�³å¼•æ�¥ç½‘络çƒçƒˆè®¨è®ºã€‚超过å…æˆ�回贴一致认为，两人最多算是å�¶åƒ�，还没有到那么崇高的地ä½�。
网民直言，“国å®�”一è¯�用得太轻率，两ä½�阿å§�虽然在娱ä¹�圈相当有æˆ�就，但还ä¸�能算是国å®�ï¼›è¦�是真è¦�戴“国å®�”的帽å�，å™ç‡•å§¿çš„“国å®�”指数还比范文芳è¦�æ�¥å¾—高。一些网å�‹è¯´ï¼Œå™ç‡•å§¿ç®—“出å�£è½¬å†…销”，但è¦�是真的勉强算作国å®�，也å�¯ç��一å�ªçœ¼é—一å�ªçœ¼ï¼Œä½†èŒƒæ–‡èŠ³æ˜¯ç»�对ä¸�å�ˆæ ¼ã€‚
还有网å�‹æ�¶æ�„说，如果两人算“国å®�”，å�ªèƒ½è¯´å¥¹ä»¬éƒ½“è€�”了。
但也有约两æˆ�网å�‹è®¤ä¸ºï¼Œä¸¤äººéƒ½æœ‰ä¸ºæ–°åŠ å�¡äº‰å…‰ï¼Œèµšé’±æ¯”较多ã€�缴税多，ç»�æµŽè´¡çŒ®ç®—å¤§ï¼Œè¿˜è®©å¾ˆå¤šå¤–å›½äººè®¤è¯†æ–°åŠ å�¡ï¼Œä¹Ÿç§°å¾—上是“国å®�”。
　　◆�对派
　　·å™ç‡•å§¿å½“国å®�还勉强算过，范文芳？算了å�§ã€‚
　　·å™ç‡•å§¿å±žäºŽ“出å�£è½¬å†…销”，é…�å† ä¸Š“国å®�”光环å�—？范文芳更ä¸�å�ˆæ ¼ã€‚
　　·èŒƒæ–‡èŠ³æ˜¯é©¬å›½åª³å¦‡äº†ï¼Œä¸�方便当“国å®�”。
　　·æ˜¯“国å®�”还是“æ´»å®�”？
　　·å›½å®�çš„å®šä¹‰åº”è¯¥æ›´ä¸¥æ ¼å�§ã€‚
　　◆支�派
　　·èµšé’±æ¯”较多ã€�缴税多，对国家的ç»�济贡献显而易è§�。
　　·èŒƒé˜¿å§�的贡献虽然ä¸�å�Šå™ç‡•å§¿ï¼Œä¸�è¿‡ä¸¤äººéƒ½æœ‰æ›¿æ–°åŠ å�¡äº‰ç‚¹å…‰ã€‚
　　·ä¸¤ä½�都是本地走到区域的艺人，让许多æŒè¿·ã€�å½±è¿·è®¤è¯†æ–°åŠ å�¡ï¼Œåº”该算ï¼�
◆黎沸辉：为什么范文芳和å™ç‡•å§¿ä¸�能是“国å®�”？
本地音ä¹�人黎沸辉å�—访时说，范ã€�å™ç»�过自身努力和付出，å�—到本地和国际业界的认å�Œå’Œå°Šé‡�，ä¸�èƒ½å› ä¸ºå¥¹ä»¬ä»ŽéŸ³ä¹�娱ä¹�圈æˆ�长，就抹æ�€å¥¹ä»¬çš„贡献。
“国际音ä¹�人看到我都问，‘ä½ ä»¬æ–°åŠ å�¡çš„å™ç‡•å§¿æ€Žä¹ˆæ ·’。”他说：“ä¸�è¦�看ä¸�得别人好，在å—眼上下功夫。”他认为，林俊æ�°ä¹Ÿç®—是“国å®�”：“å”±ã€�è·³ã€�ç¼–ã€�å†™éƒ½ä¼šï¼Œä»–æ˜¯æœ¬åœ°å‡ å��年难得的æ‰�å�。”
â—†éƒè·µçº¢ï¼š“国å®�”è§�ä»�è§�智
实践剧团艺术总监éƒè·µçº¢åˆ™ç›´è¨€ï¼Œè‡ªå·±ä»Žæœªæƒ³è¿‡è°�能当“国å®�”：“è¿™å�ªæ˜¯ä¸€ä¸ªç§°å�·ï¼Œä¹Ÿä¸�èƒ½å› ä¸ºæœ‰äº›äººæ²¡æœºä¼šè®©åˆ«äººçœ‹åˆ°ä»–çš„è´¡çŒ®ï¼Œå°±è¯´ä»–ä¸�是‘å®�’。”她认为，“国å®�”的讨论è§�ä»�è§�智，å�¯ä»¥æ˜¯å®˜æ–¹è®¤ä¸ºæœ‰åˆ†é‡�的人，值得尊é‡�和支æŒ�；也å�¯ä»¥æ˜¯æ°‘间认å�Œåœ¨æŸ�个领域有作为的人。　
◆部长议员：“国å®�”应对国家有影å“�力
å�—访的部长和议员们认为，“国å®�”ä¸�应å�ªæ˜¯æŸ�个领域的æ�°å‡ºäººæ‰�，而应是国家ä¸�å�¯æˆ–缺的å®�è—�，对国家å�Šç»�大多数国人形æˆ�巨大影å“�力的人物。国家å�‘展部å�Šæ•™è‚²éƒ¨é«˜çº§æ”¿åŠ¡éƒ¨é•¿å‚…海燕å�—访时说，范文芳和å™ç‡•å§¿çš„å��å—在区域内å“�当当，但还没有对本地艺术或多数国人带æ�¥å·¨å¤§å½±å“�。
社é�’ä½“å…¼äº¤é€šéƒ¨é«˜çº§æ”¿åŠ¡æ¬¡é•¿å¼ æ€�ä¹�说：“范ã€�å™ä¸¤äººå�¯è¯´æ˜¯éŸ³ä¹�娱ä¹�圈的æ‰�女，但若è¦�说æˆ�是国å®�，那么林俊æ�°å’Œé˜¿æ�œå°±ä¸�算是了å�—？是è¦�以奖项æ�¥åˆ†ï¼Ÿè¿˜æ˜¯è¦�以专辑数é‡�æ�¥é‰´å®šï¼Ÿ”丹戎巴葛集选区议员马炎庆则认为，称两人是“国å®�”是媒体给的一个å°�å�·ï¼Œè¿˜ä¸�具备国家代表性。
部长议员心目ä¸çš„“国å®�”：
　　①æ�Žå…‰è€€ï¼Œå†…é˜�资政，“国å®�”之泰斗
　　②�智强，本地著�导演
　　③朱晖，å‰�æ–°åŠ å�¡äº¤å“�ä¹�团音ä¹�总监ã€�指挥
　　④å�´ç´ ç�´ï¼Œæ–°åŠ å�¡èˆžè¹ˆå‰§åœºè‰ºæœ¯æ€»ç›‘，本地èŠè•¾èˆžå�›æ‹“è�’者之一
ã€€ã€€â‘¤åœ¨æ–‡åŒ–ä¼ æ‰¿å’Œå…·åŽ†å�²ä¿�ç•™æ„�义的文物
â—†“国å®�”自在人心
网民议员一致评选：�光耀
本报å�‘现，有近两æˆ�网å�‹è®¤ä¸ºï¼ŒçœŸæ£çš„国å®�是è¦�为国家作出贡献的人，内é˜�资政æ�Žå…‰è€€å°±æ˜¯å…¶ä¸ä¸€ä¸ªï¼�他们说，“国å®�”的帽å�ä¸�能éš�便扣，那些å�•ä¸ºè‡ªå·±èµšå¤šé’±çš„ä¸�能å�«“国å®�”，而æ�Žå…‰è€€å’Œä¸€äº›æ— å��英雄，æ‰�é…�å† è¿™ä¸ªç§°å�·ã€‚也有网å�‹è¯´ï¼Œçº¢å¤´å·¾ï¼ˆçº¢æ°´å±±å©†å©†ï¼‰å§�å¦¹ä»¬ä¹Ÿæœ‰èµ„æ ¼è¢«å�«ä½œå›½å®�。
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
for me i think not!
-
Fann Wong? A big NO NO...
-
Originally posted by caleb_chiang:
Fann Wong? A big NO NO...
some say she is going to marry malaysian FT, should be belonging to Malaysia property. -
syz ok la she's great....the only thing i rmb about fann wong is her mole lol
-
prc treat syz as bao but sg pple treat her as chao!
frankly speaking i find she is kinda over-rated. it's kinda sickening dat she will sing for ndp tis year yet again. is sg lack of representive? gimme Kit Chan or Mavis Hee anytime!
-
I find SYZ quite alright. She does have a great voice.
But I prefer Kit Chan many times. Ya, Kit Chan should be the national treasure.
-
u noe why ask sun yanzi to sing again?? cos few years back when they got a relatively unknown, kaira gong or gong sijia, to sing, the organisers got lambasted for getting some newcomer to perform.....
so now they ask sun yanzi back and still they get criticised...
-
syz can do nothing except singing. fann wong is at least more versatile.
-
fann is jack of all trades master of none.SYZ at least is a proven quantity at what she does best
-
eeyyeeerrrrr
i like neither syz nor fw
i rather see anime cha bor than watching them
-
Hooray!!!
http://www.omy.sg/showbiz/enews/200804/20080422_2107.html
move over bamboo stick! i want cai chun jia or mei xin to sing ndp song!
-
ok, if is 国� then shd be embalmed and buried 6 feet underground
pls do it now.
for fann wong, esp. -
i cant read chinese ):
-
Stephanie Sun... Maybe she is? at least she's popular in Mainland China. But. nah, I dont think Fann wong is. She can't even express herself well after being in the entertainment industry for like such a long time. Moreover, she's been to Hollywood if Im not wrong? (correct me if Im wrong)
Anyway, this is just my personal opinion. I think Fann wong can act but she can't speak without a script. :)
-
Jack Neo is Singapore National Treasure la!!! =X those 2... haiz.. CMI..
-
Oni some morons claim dat Fann Wong is national treasure of S'pore.
-
Originally posted by Lefti68:
Oni some morons claim dat Fann Wong is national treasure of S'pore.
They should be buried with Fann...
-
i hope they buried syz alive too. :<
-
eh? how come I dun see fascinating arguing with anyone here?
-
Originally posted by Honeybunz:
eh? how come I dun see fascinating arguing with anyone here?
Maybe dat fellow got appointment with IMH these days...
